23andMe Finds Few Negative Reactions to Genetic Tests For Cancer Mutations

Editor’s note: Pending an FDA decision, 23andMe no longer offers new customers access to health reports referred to in this post. Customers who received their health information prior to November 22, 2013 will still be able to see their health reports, but those who purchased after that time will only have access to ancestry information as well as access to their uninterpreted raw data. These new customers may receive health reports in the future dependent on FDA marketing authorization.

We know from scientific research that, in general, people don’t freak out about the results they get from personal genetic testing. When the results show an increased risk for serious illness, how do they react?

It turns out that even then, the news doesn’t trigger serious anxiety. Quite the contrary, the results, according to a new 23andMe study published today in the online academic journal PeerJ found these test results prompted people to take positive steps, including talking to their doctors and discussing the results with family members who could also be at risk.

Lead author of the study and 23andMe’s Senior Medical Director, Dr. Uta Francke said the research addresses one of the most urgent questions in the field of genetics, “namely the impact of receiving unexpected information about high genetic risk for a life threatening disease.”

In this case, the study looked at how people reacted when they learned for the first time that they carried a mutation in either the BRCA1 or BRCA2 gene that put them at higher risk for breast and ovarian cancer. Five to ten percent of breast cancers occur in women with a genetic predisposition for the disease, usually due to mutations in either the BRCA1 or BRCA2 gene. The mutations at the center of this study are responsible for a substantial number of hereditary breast and ovarian cancers among women with Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry.

The study found that those who acquired the potentially life-saving information not only took appropriate actions on their own behalf, but also notified relatives who might share that risk. In what the study described as a “cascade effect,” these relatives were tested because they were related to someone who had one of the high risk mutations. A number of relatives who were subsequently tested discovered they too had one of the high risk mutations.

The findings are important given that a frequent criticism of direct-to-consumer testing is based on the assumption that it causes either serious emotional distress or triggers deleterious actions on the part of consumers.  Individuals who learned they had the mutation said they did not suffer serious emotional distress, and did not take inappropriate actions.

The study authors suggested that broader screening of Ashkenazi Jewish women for these three BRCA mutations should be considered.”

 

 

 


  • Kati_lily

    This seems to be an encouraging set of observations, but I am concerned that your study is rather too small to pick up individuals with severe anxiety. Did you do any stats on the data? Do you give any guidance as a company to individuals with a positive result, as to where they can seek support?

    • ScottH

      Kati,
      As to you first question, the data is in the paper in terms of the number of people surveyed and their reactions. The blog post is just a summary of the results. You are correct is stating that the number of people who are part of the survey were small, but the findings are significant nonetheless. And finally, we do have resources for those who seek additional services or counseling not just for results related to Breast Cancer. 23andMe collaborates with Informed Medical Decisions, Inc., to provide you with direct access to board-certified genetic counselors that have been specifically trained to guide you through your 23andMe results. Learn more about their independent genetic counseling services on their website, Informed DNA. The National Society of Genetic Counselors (NSGC) also provides a list of genetic counselors that can be searched by location and specialty.

Return to top